Review: Anne of Ingleside by L. M. Montgomery

My rating: ⭐⭐

This book was sweet, though I didn’t see much point in its existence. With the other add in book, Anne of Windy Willows, it filled a clear gap in Anne’s life that had been missed in the original books. However, with this book, it filled a much more random amount of time, from long after Anne’s House of Dreams had ended to a few months before Rainbow Valley starts. I was that interested in that allotted time, or maybe I would have been more interested in it if the book had been different.

By that I mean that similarly to Rainbow Valley, this book followed scores of perspectives and I didn’t much care for most of them. I think had I not read Rainbow Valley and Rilla of Ingleside this book would have been confusing because of the sheer number of children who had a perspective in this story, yet this book is supposed to be set before them…

Aside from that, it was a sweet enough book about the trials and tribulations of childhood, though childhood from an advantaged perspective, and touched on the issues a marriage can face as children and work take over, which I thought was interesting. Overall though, there wasn’t enough to tie this book together to justify its creation, though at least not everyone loved Anne! (Though of course most people did.)

[Goodreads parallel]

Review: Anne of Windy Willows by L. M. Montgomery

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐

Like a lot of the books in the Anne of Green Gables series, this is another simple, light read. The threading of a continual storyline was a bit better throughout this book rather than just following Anne through a random period, thinking particularly of her neighbour Elizabeth, as happened in the other books around this time in Anne’s life. However, it still wasn’t overly impressive.

As with the previous books, how much Anne is liked by everyone is more than a bit irksome and even the people that don’t like her eventually love her! The singular time Anne made an enemy by her actions, it is made to seem like that character is completely unreasonable because of course, no one can hate Anne for an actual reason. (The urge to roll my eyes is overwhelming.)

Aside from that, a complete lack of Gilbert’s presence in this book was a bit disappointing. It might speak to the time, but by missing out that part of Anne’s life, both in terms of visits and omitting parts of her letters, it just made the book a bit lacking and less realistic.

[Goodreads parallel]

Review: Rilla of Ingleside by L. M. Montgomery

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐1/2

This was by far the best book in the Anne of Green Gables series. Rilla was such a well-developed character and you could so clearly see her change and progress throughout the book. This book made me laugh at some of the awkward moments, but it also managed to make me cry at the sadder moments. What made the difference in this book was the continuing thread of the war throughout the story. It gave a driving force to everything that happened and served to bind the characters together in a way that we didn’t get to see in the previous books. I could also clearly see the development of Montgomery’s writing from her previous books and I couldn’t be happier that this was the end to the series.

[Goodreads parallel]

Review: Rainbow Valley by L. M. Montgomery

My rating: ⭐⭐

The start of this book was promising. With a new set of interesting characters, there was a chance to make a good story and an effective plot. Unfortunately, that wasn’t the case and there wasn’t enough of the likable qualities of Anne present to make up the deficit.

This is probably something that is edition specific, and I checked in the front to find that this should be the exact same version as that which was printed in 1919, but I absolutely hated the use of capitalised words within sentences for emphasis. It was something that wasn’t in previous books and seemed like a very unnecessary addition.

While the story of the Meredith’s was initially interesting, eventually it just became a repetition of the same story, but with a different child punishing themselves for stepping out of line. To keep interest in the plot, for me, Mr Meredith would have had to have come to his senses sooner and started acting like a proper father. However, the way the plot is, the story became far too predictable and boring.

There’s a lot more that I could say about this book, but I want to avoid ranting, so I’ll make one more comment, which fittingly is about the final part of the book. Out of nowhere on the last page, the narration starts to talk about the coming future, specifically the war. I completely understand the relevance of this, with the book being published in 1919, but it seemed completely out of place from the rest of the book and really drew me away from the story. When reading a book that forms part of a series, you want to be encouraged to stay in that world a little longer and by having that part tacked onto the end, it did the opposite for me.

If there wasn’t only one book left in the series, I would be severely tempted to stop reading after this book.

[Goodreads parallel]

Review: Anne's House of Dreams by L. M. Montgomery

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐

This was another quick and enjoyable read from the Anne of Green Gables series. There wasn’t an oversaturation of side-characters as there had been in other books with enough mention of characters outside of the periphery to remind you that they still existed without it becoming overwhelming. The side-characters that were present were well developed and I found myself caring about them more than previous ones, especially the story about Leslie and Dick/George Moore.

However, Anne’s pregnancies and the loss of baby Joyce, I feel, were handled poorly. Firstly, I didn’t even realise Anne was pregnant until she was almost giving birth in both cases and secondly, the loss of Joyce was covered only in half as much detail as I thought would be necessary for the reader and Anne to understand the weight of the situation. I understand that I’m writing this from a modern perspective where child mortality levels are much lower and post-natal depression and other related topics are discussed more openly, but brushing this storyline aside so quickly, in my opinion, did this book a great disservice.

[Goodreads parallel]

Review: Anne of the Island by L. M. Montgomery

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐

Though I enjoyed reading this book, the parts of the first two books in the Anne of Green Gables series that I didn’t like only became more amplified in this novel.

Firstly, everyone seems to love Anne. In the first couple of books I would go along with this to a certain extent because a lot of the people introduced were children and Anne herself was a child, so you have people who are likely to like someone on first impression and someone who is easily likable. But in this book, the stream of people who adored Anne for seemingly nothing was endless. If I am counting right, she was proposed to six times by five different people and some of them she barely knew. Did they propose just because she is that likable? I wouldn’t mind as much if proper reason was given to them liking her, but I couldn’t find much to suggest that she would be so universally adored.

Secondly, there was another large introduction of secondary characters in this book. This was of course necessary with Anne going to study at Redmond, but a lot were never expanded upon more than appearance and Anne’s opinion on them. It got annoying because I wanted to be able to form my own opinion on them based on their actions, but it seemed that most of their actions only reflected the necessary points of Anne’s plot. It’s a shame because I feel like this book would have been so much richer if it hadn’t been that way.

Having said all that, I did still enjoy this book and I did want to know what was going to happen in Anne’s life, though I do think the main reason was to see whether Anne and Gilbert would end up together, which I knew already, but still interested me.

[Goodreads parallel]

Review: Anne of Avonlea by L. M. Montgomery

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

If it wasn’t for the story of Miss Lavender that started fairly late on in the book, this would have been 3 stars rather than 4 stars, though in truth it is more like 3.5 stars. This is because there seemed to be no set purpose to the book until that point, it was merely just some assorted stories from Anne’s life framed at either end by her starting and ending teaching in Avonlea. That isn’t to say that I didn’t enjoy reading those stories, but there was nothing to keep me reading because they could be so easily separated. Still, I did enjoy how wholesome this book was and the comedic moments.

[Goodreads parallel]

Review: Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

My rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

I decided to read this book after watching the Netflix adaptation. The start of the novel was just as charming and it was wonderful to see Anne transition from a young orphan without meaningful relationships to a graduate of Queen’s college with supportive friends and family around her to support her.

My only criticism of this book is that I wish there was more to it. A lot of time was spent on Anne’s journey to Green Gables and her initial time in Avonlea, but as the book progressed, there was less and less time spent on each part of Anne’s life and it’s something that I would have really loved to read more about, especially her time at Queen’s. I’m just glad she’s still fairly young at the end of this novel so there’s still a lot of her story to be told in the other books.

[Goodreads parallel]